Newton Pizza

Discover Newton Pizza at 274 Spring St, Newton, NJ. Enjoy delicious Sicilian pizza, crispy crust, subs, buffalo chicken pizza, mussels, stromboli, garlic knot sandwiches, and a friendly, cozy atmosphere. Call +1 973-383-6525 today!

View MenuContact

Welcome to Newton Pizza

Experience the finest dining

Newton Pizza
Newton Pizza
Newton Pizza
Newton Pizza

Newton Pizza, located at 274 Spring St in Newton, NJ, offers a delightful experience for pizza enthusiasts and food lovers alike. With a cozy atmosphere and friendly staff, this eatery serves up a mouthwatering selection of Sicilian pizza, subs, and hot sandwiches. The menu bursts with flavor, featuring specialties like Buffalo chicken pizza and delectable mussels. Whether you crave a fresh pie with a crispy crust or a satisfying garlic knot sandwich, Newton Pizza has something to satisfy every appetite. Lunchtime here is particularly bustling, especially on Fridays. It's a great spot to visit with friends or family for a relaxed meal, making it a beloved local gem.

The interior of Newton Pizza radiates a warm and inviting vibe, perfect for families and food adventurers. Their extensive menu holds over 130 dishes, ensuring variety for every palate. Guests can dive into hearty options like baked ravioli or indulge in traditional favorites, including stromboli and calzone. Newton Pizza also boasts a delightful selection of desserts such as cannoli and zeppoles—perfect for that sweet ending. The casual dining area encourages a community feel where locals gather. For those on the go, takeout and delivery options make enjoying a meal at Newton Pizza easy and convenient. Peak hours see full tables, particularly on Fridays and Saturdays, but visiting during off-peak times provides a relaxed experience.

Location & Contact

The Setting

Address

274 Spring St, Newton, NJ 07860, United States

Phone

+1 973-383-6525

About

The Journey Behind the Flavor

Newton Pizza
Newton Pizza
Newton Pizza
Newton Pizza

Newton Pizza stands out in the local dining scene for its dedication to quality and flavor. Nestled in the heart of Newton, it has become a favorite for those seeking authentic Italian dishes. With an average of two dozen hot sandwiches and specialty pizzas on hand, the diverse menu draws in visitors from all over. The establishment prides itself on its use of fresh ingredients, ensuring that each item, whether it's a classic cheese pizza or a loaded meatball sub, delivers satisfying taste with every bite.

The neighbourhood atmosphere adds to the charm.

Regulars have made it their go-to spot for casual dining, especially on Fridays when the restaurant fills to capacity for lunch. Those who like to plan ahead should note that the best times to visit are after the midday rush. Their most popular menu items, including Buffalo chicken pizza, offer distinctive flavors that keep diners returning.

Newton Pizza’s commitment also shines through their friendly and knowledgeable staff.

They are eager to help with recommendations and ensure that every guest feels welcome. It’s common to see returning customers exchanging smiles and greetings with the crew, further solidifying Newton Pizza’s role as a community hub. Special events and family nights occasionally take place, fostering camaraderie among locals. The vibe here is relaxed yet vibrant—perfect for families to enjoy a warm meal together or for friends to unwind over pizza and drinks.

Newton Pizza

The exterior of Newton Pizza radiates a classic pizzeria charm, inviting diners to step inside. Bright signage and charming outdoor seating capture the essence of casual dining. The cozy ambiance continues outdoors, where patrons can enjoy their meals al fresco, especially during pleasant weather. The surrounding area features a quaint neighborhood vibe, making it a delightful spot to stow away and relax with a slice or two. Passersby often stop to admire the inviting entrance, emphasizing the restaurant’s appeal to both locals and newcomers.

Work Hours

Reservations & Service Hours

  • Sunday11 AM-5 PM
  • MondayClosed
  • Tuesday11 AM-9 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM-9 PM
  • Thursday11 AM-9 PM
  • Friday11 AM-10 PM
  • Saturday11 AM-9 PM

Guestbook & Reviews

Customer Reviews

Pizza was crazy fresh crispy with a bubble crust! The guys there were super friendly! Everyone that walked in was super friendly. Just a great place to go! They were making fresh dough when I walked in!

N
Nelson S.

PERFECTION !!! The half-and-half pie we devoured at this pizza restaurant was AMAZING !!! With chicken parm on one side and buffalo chicken on the other, the combination of crispy crust, tangy sauce, melted cheese, and generous juicy chicken was flawless. Hands down, this was the BEST pizza we have ever had! Friendly service, too. If you're a pizza lover, then this is a must go place.

A
Aon

Was my first time trying Newton Pizza at either the old or their current new location. So far on first impressions my rating is 5 stars. The new location is nice. You walk in and the first thing you see is inside of the kitchen. It's different and not sure if intentional or not, but it allows the customer to see where your food is coming from. It appeared clean and organized. Walk past that and you reach the dining area and the counter. Dinner area and the counter are pretty close, maybe even a little cramped but I ordered take out so no big deal. The lady on the counter was very pleasant. Customer service these days is very important, it's always a good experience to be greeted and promptly taken care of. I ordered a white pie with broccoli. I'd say the pizza was better than expected. Crust isn't really too thin or thick. It's thick enough so you can pick up a slice with out it being a mess but not so thick that there's too much of it. The pizza came out to $17 and change which I thought was a bit high, but I won't knock a place until I try the food and I think the quality of the pizza probably justifies the price. The only knock was that I could not find a menu anywhere online before hand. Had I of had a menu prior to ordering I probably would of ordered more but didn't feel like playing 20 questions when calling to place my order. So I've provided pictures of the current menu. I don't know if the prices change frequently or not so I'll say that the menu is as of 9/6/17. I will definitely be trying more items off the menu and would recommend Newton pizza over at least one of the other local pizza places. Hopefully future experiences are the same.

T
Tom H.

Great pizza! My daughter loved the slice she had and the stromboli was very delicious. The best sauce I've had in a very long time. Highly recommended!

S
Steve L.

My children grew up on this families pizza from Tommy to his dad Zep to uncle and cousin! When you get the pizza there as we have at there previous locations, the Pizza taste as if it's all done by the same hands, well they were all family! I went there the other day got an Italian sub and was not disappointed the bread really good the ingredients on my sandwich all fresh! The pizza great as always! Plus there staff great people, friendly makes me feel at home! Been going to these guys for food since 2007 still the same! My favorite Pizza spot! Stand up team! Thank you all for your great service to Newton!

C
Christian

One of if not the best pizza places in north jersey love this place.

l
luke s.